Sunday, July 29, 2012

What did La Perdida do for you?

When I first began reading "La Perdida" by Jessica Abel I began to understand very quickly that this women was only heading down a rough path. I can relate to Abel's character Cara when she begins to start thinking that she wants something new in her life. How she began to understand her new life was an utter mess but in the end, the lesson was very prominent. The lesson that I took away from this book is that you can be who you want to be where ever you would like. To force a culture upon yourself without learning where the culture derives from is a pure misconception for Carla.

I found Carla to be completely misguided. Yes, I understood that she wanted to learn about her heritage in Mexico but why did she think she could do it by herself. She closed many doors off as soon as her idiotic ex-boyfriend tried to put her on the streets. I found it humeros that Carla and her ex-boyfriend Harry were both being held captive under these so called "real mexicans". Why would I find it humeros? Humeros because the analogy that was being made by Abel was so true for Carla and Harry.

Both of the Americans thought they could live in a culture, thrive in a culture and even learn about a culture without ever becoming involved in the culture. First take Harry, the spoiled journalist from Chicago that wants to isolate himself from living and breathing the mexican culture without meeting real people of the city. An alarm went off in my head when I understood this about Harry, he has been able to drift along his whole life without ethically learning about any culture or social group because of the money and life he was born into. If he had not, well thats a different story, but if he just went out into Mexico City like a normal educated journalist he may have learned that it takes knowledge, education and socially dynamics to actually learn what and who the people of mexico are.

The analogy made by Abel was fantastic, he was being kidnapped through himself and has been blaming others for his problems. Harry being kidnapped by the friends of Carla was inevitable because by Carla not becoming a real citizen of the mexican culture she stepped into an illogical revolutionary gang. Carla could not step back and look at herself because she was too scared to step in as a judge of the situation because she thought she was not qualified for dealing with the "cultural" situation that occurred.

Carla fell into a pessimistic view of other cultures and peoples. She thought that if she wanted to understand the world around her, it would come to her rather than her unraveling the adventure for herself. In effect, the world that became her culture in mexico was sublime, she could not see the real people of mexico because she was blinded by her own insecurities which led her "friends" to believe that they had a hold on her.

I loved Carla's brother because without him the conscience of Carla would have never been spoken out. His presence stood for the reality that Carla knew she was perusing but stuck in a sick twisted relationship with misguided, immoral and delusional friends. The only escape from these people was for her to accept the cultural difference and become instinctually rational for the sake of bettering herself. To conclude, I enjoyed Carla and her adventure to learn a new culture with a freed mind, but where she ended up was as captive as she could have been. The lesson I think Carla learned was that "one must coincide both points of view to understand the fluent languages being spoken between one another".

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Fun Home?

Alison Bechdel, wow! "Fun Home" was my first experience with a graphic memoir and I have to say that it was a pleasure reading and analyzing each and every sentence and graphic Bechdel created. The approach of the graphic novel is stifling to me because the usual novel read is just plain old english text with out pictures. "Fun Home" is incredibly interesting because when reading Bechdel's memoir not only was I reading deep thoughts of Alison's past but memories were drawn to show the point of view of Bechdel which was either satirical, ironic, serious or confusing.
What I mean by being shown a point of view is that Bechdel did not stick to images that were strict memories, the pictures were drawn to take the reality of many of the situations into another realm of understanding. For example, in the first chapter "Old Father, Old Artificer" Bechdel goes on to explain that her relationship with her father was tough on herself and the family. The graphic I would like to give attention to is a medium shot of Bechdel's family in the front of church with her father looking at the priest in the middle of the picture with an utter look of guilt on his face. The only other person looking straight at the priest in church is Alison who is next to her father with her arm keeping her bored looking face afloat. The text above the picture reads "He appeared to be an ideal husband and father, for example". Then below inside the picture reads, "But would an ideal husband and father have sex with teenage boys?"
I found this picture and statement so powerful and enticing because thats where her reversal was placed, thats where she begins her adventurous journey explaining who her father really is and how she became the woman she is today. Not only does the picture and text begin to introduce the problems Bechdel is likely to run into but the setting of being in church with a priest in the picture was a satirical joke about the Catholic Church. So many points are to be analyzed in every picture Bechdel correlates within the text and picture.
What I noticed which was different than many of the novels I have read is that the chronological order Bechdel used was strategically unique. Without the comics of the characters that Bechdel encounters through out her life the intertextuality does not make sense. With the comics, short letters of the past and dialoge from the characters the chronological story makes sense and displays many emotions of Bechdel. "A Happy Death" is the second chapter where Bechdel thoroughly explains how she reacted to the death of her father. Step by step I am going to try to explain how Bechdel begins the chapter "A Happy Death" and why the death is not happy whatsoever.

  1. First, she is at the Funeral home while friends and family grieve the death of Bechdel's father.
  2. Does not show compassion because Bechdel believe her father could have committed suicide
  3. Explains his grave, an obelisk, a symbol of life for her father
  4. Then questions why her father and mother were even married and how her parents relationship developed.
  5. In and out of daily tasks of her parents then to a grave digger and Bechdel as a child with her father asking to "Jump in" the grave being dug.
  6. Grandmother telling a story to Bechdel about her father as a 3 year getting stuck in the mud and the "milk man" having to find and return him to his mother. 
  7. Then the introduction of "fun home", a funeral home, and the surgical procedures that her father did as a cadaver.
  8. Bechdel in college getting the call of the bad news
  9. John (Bechdel's brother) and Alison then meet fo the first time after the death and cannot stop grinning at one another without understanding why?
  10. A passage of "Sisyphus" about suicide.
  11. Bechdel's father in surgery with a corpse.
  12. Back to the funeral home
  13. Her fathers grave and above reads "Stuck in the mud for good this time" 
Why I think that these points are important in the understanding of the memoir's chronology is because her thoughts are very poignant but necessary for the understanding of character development. The character development is strange because of the short chronological spasms that relate to Bechdel's story telling technique. Only bits and pieces of every character are introduced because for the reader to understand why Bechdel developed the way she did was through past memories that are snap shots of the past. The snap shots give the reader the ability to empathize Bechdel by seeing and reading the situational conflicts that occur in her life. 
The coming of age story was far from predictable, when the last chapter came to an end and how Bechdel and her father exchanged scholarly understandings of text Bechdel became emotionally parallel with her father. The books that Bechdel read helped herself understand who she was by analyzing who her father was. In conclusion Bechdel began to live once her father died because she finally she could understand and relieve herself from his point of view how horrible it was to live under a self generated burden of homosexuality.